| Tampa Bay 1 0 1 0_2 | |
| Toronto 1 0 1 1_3 | |
| First Period_1, Tampa Bay, St. Louis 25 (Lee, Malone), 5:49. 2, Toronto, T.Connolly 13 (Gardiner, Steckel), 6:32. Penalties_Mikkelson, TB (hooking), 9:27. | |
| Second Period_None. Penalties_Brewer, TB (holding), 15:30. | |
| Third Period_3, Tampa Bay, Stamkos 59 (Gervais, St. Louis), 8:48. 4, Toronto, Gardiner 7, 17:05. Penalties_None. | |
| Overtime_5, Toronto, Phaneuf 11 (Kessel), 4:01. Penalties_None. | |
| Shots on Goal_Tampa Bay 8-17-12-0_37. Toronto 13-5-11-2_31. | |
| Power-play opportunities_Tampa Bay 0 of 0 | Toronto 0 of 2. |
| Goalies_Tampa Bay, Roloson 12-16-3 (31 shots-28 saves). Toronto, Scrivens 4-4-2 (37-35). | |
| A_19,369 (18,819). T_2:34. | |
| Referees_Paul Devorski, Steve Kozari. Linesmen_Brad Kovachik, Derek Nansen. |