Skip to main content

How well every MLB team has drafted

WASHINGTON — A lot goes into running the baseball operations department of a baseball club. Finding players, drafting or signing them, developing them, trading them, releasing them — all in all, trying to maximize the value of the talent available to you. It makes the question “is your team’s GM doing a good job?” an endlessly complex one to answer.

But what we can measure is how well teams have drafted talent, given the draft picks available to them.

That second part is crucial. Sure, the Nationals nabbed consensus top picks two straight years in Stephen Strasburg and Bryce Harper (2009-10), but they had the top overall pick due to how poorly the big league club had performed the years prior. With that in mind, we’ve attempted to measure how well each Major League club has drafted with the picks available to them since the Nationals moved to Washington, up through the 2012 draft.

When judging the success of these picks, we’ve taken their career accumulated WAR (per Baseball Reference) and divided it by an expected value. That expected value is derived from a chart of how much WAR players in the Baseball America Top 100 contributed, on average, over their next seven seasons. As a Top 100 ranking is essentially an updated draft ranking, this gives us an idea of how well players regarded and drafted so high actually compared with their baseline.

Many of these players made the majors with clubs other than the ones that they were drafted by, and a great majority of them played for multiple clubs. It would be near-impossible to try to calculate the value they’ve accumulated with each club through each and every trade. That is not the intent here. This is simply to see how the players the organization inked to contracts and initially invested in actually panned out as major leaguers.

So with no further ado, here are the rankings for each club, as well as the top three players in draft value.

[custom_gallery]

WATCH: Nats celebrate World Series with parade ahead of Spring Training opener in Florida

The Washington Nationals showed off their trophy from winning the 2019 World Series in front of their local fans in South Florida during a parade on Thursday, February 20. Spring Training kicked off recently, and the first preseason game is Saturday, February 22, against the Houston Astros, the team they defeated in the World Series. Before the parade started, Michael A. Taylor and Sean Doolittle mingled with fans, some of whom were wearing hats supporting the local Miami Marlins. However, the West Palm Beach fans showed their support, as players like Kurt Suzuki, Trea Turner and Howie Kendrick rode in cars and buses through the main streets of Clemantis.
Read Next Story