Skip to main content

Financial Advisors vs. Robo-Advisors: Which is Right for You?

One recurring theme of the 21st century has been the ascendance of automation technologies that replace human workers. For example, the travel industry has changed dramatically in the past 15 years, as people bypass a local agent and head for Expedia, Orbitz or Priceline.

The financial services industry is also in the throes of a transformation. The baby boom generation is retiring en masse, registered investment advisors are replacing traditional stock brokers, regulatory scrutiny is on the rise and so-called “robo-advisors” are offering investment management outside the confines of a traditional financial advisor’s office.

Robo-advisors use algorithms and model portfolios to allocate investments according to a client’s particular objectives and risk tolerance. They are not equipped to provide more detailed and nuanced financial planning services, which are the specialty of traditional advisory firms. Some of the larger robo-advisor firms are Wealthfront, Betterment and FutureAdvisor.

Michael Kitces is a partner and director of planning research at Pinnacle Advisory Group in Columbia, Maryland. He also runs a blog on financial planning, Nerd’s Eye View, and consults the advisory industry on best practices, industry trends and planning strategies. He explains that the business of a robo-advisor is very narrow.

“Robo-advisors are basically designed to do one thing: give you an asset-allocated passive strategic portfolio,” he says. Wealthfront, for example, has billed itself as “The Automated Investment Service for Everyone.”

“That’s the scope of what they do, period. If someone wants actual advice about anything beyond ‘Give us your money and we’ll invest your portfolio in a diversified manner,’ you’re outside the capabilities of robo-advisors and into working with an actual financial advisor,” Kitces says.

Mary Beth Storjohann, founder of Workable Wealth, a San Diego firm specializing in financial planning for Generation Y, meets with clients in person, but also uses the Internet to work with clients throughout the country and holds meetings using technologies such as Skype or Google Hangouts.

She says traditional advisors and robo-advisors offer complementary services, and clients can use both services for financial planning.

As a certified financial planner, she views investing as a piece of the overall planning puzzle. “Let’s say you have a Roth [individual retirement account], and you’re not sure what to do with it,” Storjohann says. “… as a financial planner, I’ll say, ‘Do you have your emergency fund in place?’ … I’m going to look at the whole picture. Even in the most basic of situations, there are a few more questions that need to be asked before someone says, ‘I have a pot of money, let’s invest it.'”

However, once she’s determined the proper investment strategy, Storjohann says it could be appropriate to send a client to a robo-advisor for the actual portfolio implementation.

“Being an online advisor, I would go to an online firm like Betterment before I went to a commission broker,” she says. “It fits with my model. I’m already online. My clients are online. A robo-advisor is easy to use and seamless. It’s complementary service, versus me being online and trying to refer to somebody who’s a little more old-school with an office and more barriers.”

Accessibility is one area in which robo-advisors hold appeal for tech-savvy investors, regardless of age. Jon Stein, CEO of Betterment, points out that it’s not only Generation Y or millennial investors who use his company’s service. One quarter of his customers are over age 50.

Kitces also says it’s something of a myth that younger investors are turning in droves to online advisors, considering that a small portion of investors are using these services. But as millennials age and roll employer-sponsored plans from the 401(k) structure and into IRAs, that will likely change. At the moment, however, robo-advisors account for only a tiny fraction of the overall investment management industry.

Stein views Betterment as complementing, rather than detracting from, traditional financial planners. In October, his firm launched Betterment Institutional, an automated platform giving financial advisors access to Betterment’s portfolio models and other capabilities.

“We built it due to popular demand. We had heard from so many advisors that they wanted to leverage our portfolio construction. They wanted to leverage our automated tax-loss harvesting,” he says. Tax-efficient portfolio rebalancing is another feature available to advisors on the Betterment platform.

Stein says many financial advisors are using his firm’s capabilities as an adjunct to other portfolio models they design themselves. This gives them more time for financial and estate planning, as well as more time to spend with clients rather than managing stock and bond portfolios.

David Lyon, CEO of Main Street Financial in Chicago, offers traditional financial planning and investment advisory services to high-net-worth individuals as well as a Web-based service for younger clients or those with fewer assets to manage. He sees a role for both in-person and Web-based services but cautions that not all aspects of the process can be automated.

“There’s not really an algorithm to help investors get through periods of market volatility. A lot of investing is emotionally based, as it relates to the market,” he says. In other words, a traditional planner can provide more hand-holding and coaching through rough patches in the market.

However, Lyon believes the traditional investment advisory business is not always friendly to younger investors. That’s where online investing technologies play an important role.

“Technology is really a way to help people get connected and stay connected, of making investing accessible,” he says. “What we’ve done here is to provide technology that helps people connect to their goals and what’s ultimately important to them.”

More from U.S. News

12 Financial Terms Every Investor Should Know

Beware of These 10 Scary Investments

8 Retirement Milestones That Affect Your Investment Decisions

Financial Advisors vs. Robo-Advisors: Which is Right for You? originally appeared on usnews.com

Don’t Settle for Student Loans to Pay for Online Education

Online college programs are becoming a more popular choice for prospective students, with one study finding that more than 6 million students enrolled in at least one online course in fall 2015. The popularity of these courses can be attributed in part to their flexibility with working adults' schedules, students' ability to progress more quickly through online programs and, oftentimes, cheaper tuition. [See 10 low-cost online bachelor's programs for out-of-state students.]Online degrees can be beneficial to many college students, but some studies have shown online learners complete their programs at lower rates than students at traditional brick-and-mortar campuses. Individuals with student loans but no degree comprise two-thirds of defaulted borrowers. Though these numbers are not encouraging, just like for traditional programs, there are ways to reduce how much you'll need to borrow for an online program to ensure you won't become one of these statistics. Don't just settle on borrowing student loans to cover the whole cost of your program and living expenses. Instead, start thinking about how to cut costs and cover your balance in different ways, such as the following. -- Grants and scholarships: Even though you are taking an online course, you can still apply and receive grants and scholarships. But your first step should be to complete the Free Application for Federal Student Aid, commonly referred to as the FAFSA, which will allow you to receive a Pell Grant if your expected family contribution is low enough. The EFC criteria and award amounts are adjusted annually, but the 2017-2018 academic year awards range from $606 to $5,920, which could significantly lower the amount you borrow annually. Your next step is to apply for scholarships. You can start by checking online scholarship search engines, such as the Salt Scholarship Search, College Board's BigFuture and Peterson's. But don't forget to take advantage of local organizations and your school's financial aid office. Both may offer scholarships that you can't find with a national scholarship search. [Review these 10 sites to kick off your scholarship search.]For instance, organizations like the Elks Club, Knights of Columbus or the Rotary Club typically offer scholarships annually to local students. Just because you're going to school online doesn't mean you're ineligible. Visit your local library for scholarship listings, and ask around town. You might be surprised how many local organizations offer scholarships. While these scholarships typically aren't large, every little bit counts. Each dollar you receive in a scholarship is a dollar you don't have to borrow and pay interest on. -- Work-study: Another option for online students may be work-study awards. Not all students enrolled in online programs are eligible, but students at some schools -- including, for example, SUNY Empire State College and Liberty University -- are. Work-study awards are not given upfront like scholarships and grants. In most cases, they are an offer to earn up to the awarded amount if you secure an eligible work-study job. While there is a misconception that all work-study jobs must be on campus, students can work for off-campus, nonprofit or public employers as long as the work is in the public's interest. You may be able to work for a for-profit employer if the job is relevant to your course of study. No matter who the outside employer is, it will need to have an established agreement with your college for you to receive work-study funds. Remember, to be eligible for federal financial aid, you must be enrolled and pursuing a degree or certificate. If you're not working toward a credential, Pell Grants and work-study won't be option, but you may still be able to take advantage of private scholarships -- just be sure to read the eligibility criteria carefully. [Explore what to know about financial aid in online programs.]-- Pay as you go: One of the great benefits to enrolling online is the flexible schedule, which can allow you to complete your college coursework around your responsibilities. But prospective students often overlook using their part- or full-time job earnings as an option for paying for college. Almost 80 percent of college students in 2015 worked at least part time while attending classes, according to the National Center for Education Statistics. By budgeting and thinking strategically about your college costs, you can likely reduce your dependence on student loans by paying a portion out of pocket. Many -- but not all -- online programs are less expensive than traditional programs and often have shorter payment periods. Six, eight or 10 weeks are common course durations. Because of the frequency of payments in an online setting, you may be well-placed to pay as you go and possibly avoid borrowing altogether. Attending college online and avoiding student loans may be challenging, but if you are willing to put in the effort, you can limit the amount you need to borrow. More from U.S. News Q&A: Understanding Student Loan Discharge Eligibility Student Loan Refinancing Isn't Right for All Borrowers
Read Next Story